Overview & Reviews

The big news for the 2005 Mini Cooper is the arrival of the convertible in both regular and S flavors. Stylish as ever, the drop-top Mini seats four and still has a trunk big enough for a few bags. Other changes include slightly revised front and rear fascias and some reworked option choices. The vanity mirrors are no longer illuminated, a universal remote transmitter is now available and a leather-wrapped steering wheel is now standard. The S version gains 5 horsepower and 7 pound-feet of torque, as well as an external temperature display. Both the five- and six-speed manual transmissions feature shorter gearing this year to improve acceleration. A six-speed automatic transmission will become available on the S versions later in the model year.

• Not enough horsepower in base model, questionable seat comfort, not much room for passengers and cargo, some low-grade interior materials.

User Reviews:

Showing 11 through 20 of 256.00

• 

  Love the Look, Spotty Reliability - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By UnsureMini - July 3 - 11:43 am

  Ordered our MINI back 2004 to exact specs.. We paid MSRP but we got exactly what we wanted. The MINI was nearly perfect with Free oil changes and normal maintenance until 36K. The exception of around 29K, AC unit was replaced. Around 60K the engine mounts and bushings ($700) had to be replaced and then around 100K the oxygen sensor went out with some other parts around it. MINI refused to pay even though it was a known issue ($900 we paid) Later, Clutch 114K ($1700), 114k Cylinder #1 died on the freeway ($2700.) If you keep this car over 100K, find an independent shop, the cost is half. The dealers charges $300 for an oil change, some areas $400.

• 

  Overall not bad - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By jmargolis - April 19 - 10:03 pm

  Generally, Ive been very happy with my Mini. Ive had one ABS sensor go bad and my power steering hose needed replacing for a leak. There are very occasional inexplicable computer problems, as well. Overall, performance and handling are very good, though the stock run-flats on a sport suspension and springs make for a rough ride. The interior is nice (I prefer the pre-2007 interior) but a little "plasticky"; would be nice if they offered JCW leather upgrade for more than just the dash and down tubes (e.g., the door panels).

• 

  Service stinks! - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By *** - March 30 - 7:26 pm

  While I love driving my 2-week old Mini, the service available stinks! After only having my Mini for 2 weeks, the Service Engine light came on and the car lost power. When I called my BMW dealer, they told me I could get in 1 week later! They only have 1 Mini repair person! I also called area BMW dealers and havent received return calls. Be careful when buying this car to ensure there are more certified repair people for MINI in your area!

• 

  I love my Go-Cart! - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By Chris M - March 1 - 1:30 am

  In spite of having the automatic transmission completely replaced and losing some of my faith in my car because of it, I still love driving it. The fuel economy vs. performance cant be matched. This car has a good quality feel but the ride can be a little rough at times. A long trip will leave you feeling fatigued. It is responsive and quick. However, I have had issues with people in huge SUVs not seeing me and almost moving over on me. :)

• 

  i luv my mini* - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By mini-bmw - January 29 - 2:00 am

  i bought my mini s when he was 5 years old w/65k on him. no problems w/ole mini, 10k miles & 8 months later. we seem thirstier than usual in regards to drinking oil & water-no leaks found. the mini people are more expensive than others, but its German. the BMW feel is felt throughout- quality, handling, throttle, & performance overall. its true w/the German autos; the harder you drive em, the better they perform. the kick down is nice-no problems passing others. holds the road well, rain or shine. ive had none of the issues others have mentioned. i dont think the mini was meant for stop & go traffic, it likes to run the roads. unlike others, i keep up on my maintenance. more than oil changes.

• 

  greaaat fun - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By blk - April 13 - 5:33 am

  Fun car to drive-- cant wait to go drive----larger than you think--faster than most people think with larger engine--gets better the more you drive-- easier to get in and out of than a Z4 or similar sports cars. Most fun I have ever had driving a car.

• 

  First of MINI - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By Gretta0326 - April 1 - 8:30 am

  This is one of the most fun cars I have ever driven. I went with the automatic but really wish I had gone with the manual S version. It handles fabulously and is a must-have if you have to park in the city.

• 

  Cute Car, Expensive up keep - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By redthirteen - February 15 - 2:00 am

  I love the look of the Mini. I love driving the mini it actually makes driving in traffic fun. But once you have to fix something on your mini, it can be very expensive. Once your car is out of warranty, Mini USA refuses to take any responsibility for their cars. They will not fix even a manufacturers defect, and cover themselves by saying it is out of the 3 year warranty. They are cute cars but are not made to last.

• 

  Fun? Yes...but aphathetic service... - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By DeeDubya - December 7 - 11:53 am

  I wanted a vehicle that was fun to drive and good on gas. The MINI S has delivered on those counts. But, the engine has developed a cold start stumble and nearly stalled in traffic the other day. BMW calls it a "low idle problem". The service department has "made a note of my concern", but would not look at the car. Ive owned it 7 months, but Im looking for another vehicle. One needs a thick skin at BMW/MINI Service departments. Sales departments are all sweetness and light, but the real truth can be found at service. Wait for the 2007 engine redesign if you want this car.

• 

  In case you were wondering... - 2005 Mini Cooper
  By Penny - October 28 - 3:20 am

  This has been a fun little car with more room than previously anticipated. For comuters who are willing to forego a smooth ride for great gas mileage or someone who likes to be looked at, this is the car for you. Personally, I am enjoying this car. I wasnt even interested in buying it because I had an SUV and thought it was to small, I was wrong! This car is fun and sexy at the same time, who would have thought! One thing that is confusing, the car has beaucoup gadgets, but is missing standard perks ie; auto tint rearview mirror or digital compass this was standard on a base Saturn. Those items are kind of a no brainer.